Papa John's Pizza - Sturgis: Fresh Pizza, Outstanding Service

Welcome to Papa John's Pizza - Sturgis, a pizza paradise nestled within the BIG D #46 Travel Plaza at 2800 Junction Ave, Sturgis, SD. This restaurant epitomizes the classic pizza experience while bringing a contemporary flair to its dishes. Renowned for its hand-tossed crust that is delightfully light and non-greasy, Papa John's offers a refreshing alternative to other well-known pizza chains. Here, you'll find toppings that burst with freshness, making every bite a delightful journey.

What truly sets Papa John's Pizza - Sturgis apart is not only the quality of the food but the stellar customer service that keeps patrons coming back for more. Customers like Reggie Rhoden rave about the delicious garlic butter and the best buffalo wings in town, all at an affordable price. The team prioritizes your satisfaction, as evidenced by manager Matt's commitment to ensuring every order is fulfilled even amidst a busy service.

The cozy atmosphere provides the perfect spot to grab a meal on the go; just as Abbey Coyle advises, a phone call ahead guarantees your pizza will be ready for pickup. And if you visit on a Friday, be sure to fill up your tank, as pizza discount coupons are available for those who fuel up at the plaza.

While there may have been hiccups, like the temporary unavailability of the popular Papadia sandwiches and the unfortunate loss of their phone line, the dedication of the staff to deliver outstanding food remains unwavering. As Brenda Bornsheuer notes, despite some ordering frustrations, the “Works” pizza is nothing short of exceptional.

Whether you're a local or just passing through, Papa John's Pizza - Sturgis promises to satisfy your pizza cravings with quality ingredients, passionate service, and a welcoming environment. With a phone number of +1 605-720-4055, your next pizza night is just a call away!

Takeaway
Dine-in

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance

Credit cards
Debit cards

Reggie Rhoden

07/10/2025

Hand tossed crust is amazing and isn't caked in grease *cough dominoes and pizza hut *cough and the topping are always fresh. Their garlic butter is amazing and they sell the best/most affordable buffalo wings of ANY place in town.

Abbey Coyle

08/08/2025

Great little pizza stop! Call ahead and it will be ready. Make sure to fill up with fuel on Fridays because they do pizza discount coupons!

Joe Kern

28/07/2025

Stopped by the Sturgis store for a pizza, I had a coupon. The Manager, Matt was upfront with me and said it's going to be a while. He had 18 pizzas ahead of me. I said that it was alright I'd stop by when I was back in town as I was headed to Rapid City. He suggested he would contact the Piedmont store and it would be ready by the time I got there. It all worked out just as it was meant to be, it was all due to the OUTSTANDING customer service and dedication to doing the right thing that Matt has as a manager. Kudos to your work ethic!!°

Brenda Bornsheuer

14/07/2025

I'm giving 5 stars because the pizza is awesome. But not happy that they are not serving the Papadia's at this location Also...had to order at the counter because their phone was "lost". I had been calling, trying to order for pick up. Another customer said he had an open line for his 30 mile drive. He was trying to order on his way home from work. So, while my Works pizza was bomb as always...ya'll need to get it together a bit

Your insights help other diners decide. We’ll keep your email private. Required fields are marked *